Starring: Steve Coogan, Rob Brydon, Jeremy Northam, Kelly Macdonald,
Dylan Moran, David Walliams, Ashley Jensen, Stephen Fry
Cert: 15
Released:
20th January 2006
Tristram Shandy (Coogan) is an 18th Century gentleman and wishes to tell the
story of his life. Unfortunately it's not as easy a task as one would think for
there are not many aspects of a person's life that allows for a perfectly linear
and concise narrative.
Thus, Tristram's story sweeps backwards and forwards in time as backstories
and sidelines are necessitated for each family member as they are introduced.
Mainly his family comprises of his father (Coogan again), mother, nanny and
uncle (Brydon). The occasional innocuous comment from these people is all that
is needed to forces the tale off on another tangent to derive further
explanation and elucidation.
Tristram mainly narrates the story but also steps in and out of the flashback
scenes to discuss details with the audience as well as interacting with the
ghosts of his past. But he does that as Tristram and as Steve Coogan (Coogan
again) in an attempt to draw light on an already confusing premise.
As well as Tristram's story, which never actually gets any further than his
birth (aside from a 'window incident' during his childhood to try to explain the
film's title) and Coogan stepping out of character to elucidate, matters are
complicated further by a documentary-style look behind the scenes. The film
starts with Coogan and Brydon chatting away in make-up before officially
starting and then begins to follow the cast and crew between takes behind the
scenes.
The adaptation of the novel, The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy,
Gentleman by Laurence Stern, is inextricably meshed with the making of the
film and the private affairs of Coogan which range from on-set insecurities to
behind-the-back adultery. At every turn Coogan is desperate to keep control of
every aspect of his life but is faced with constant adversity because of it.
Any novel adaptation is going to receive a certain amount of criticism
from its fans and those of The Life and Opinions of Tristram Shandy,
Gentleman could have a field day. A Cock And Bull Story is more a
compilation of scenes from the novel so seems more like a feature length sketch
show. It watches like an extended episode of Extras as Coogan nit-picks
to ensure his part is always the biggest and juggles his (fictional) private
life, Brydon incessantly rambles on about inanities, the director (Northam)
attempts to make an unmakeable film whilst financiers ponder shutting the
production down. All the while, with every reference and personal preference
made to the novel results in another adapted scene no matter how abstract
(including a black screen at one stage).
Additional complications and distractions come from an array of co-stars
including a film studies obsessed assistant (Naomie Harris), a detail intense
historical expert (Mark Williams), Coogan's girlfriend (Kelly MacDonald) and
their child and the enthusiastic 'real' star, Gillian Anderson.
It might appear to be a too clever premise on face value but with humour to
be found on every level (from puerile knob gags to 'art imitating life'
self-referential satire) it should appeal to a wide selection of viewers. Two
particular gems of in-story irony stand out. There's a sub-plot involving a
media story of Coogan's sordid sex-night with a lap dancer and then later there
are the cast's opinions of the film after a test
screening.
Ultimately this is a Coogan and Brydon film and their
on-off-screen banter is worth the ticket price alone. Coogan comes across as a
self-obsessed egotist with a wayward libido and Brydon is an innocent
fish-out-of-water amongst the film professionals. They are quite the Laurel and
Hardy.
A Cock And Bull Story is an adaptation of the themes of the novel
rather than the actual story itself. The themes of the film are the notions that
life is complicated, chaotic, unplannable and loaded with disappointment and
isolation. It could be deemed to be an incredibly clever, multilayered,
postmodern satire that keeps the audience on its toes with its convoluted
references. At the same time it could be deemed to have its head so far up
itself that it's a series of private jokes that ultimately just alienate the
audience.
I loved it but the Mrs didn't. Go figure.